A Comparison of Cooling Systems for High Pressure Pumps

Concerning the cooling system, the company offers a few alternatives: Water cooler, air cooler or a combination of both. Which of these alternatives is the best one depends on the installation parameters of each individual installation.

Functional Principles of the different Cooling Systems

Models with a water cooler introduce the cooling water through a connection on the rear bulkhead of the machine. A solenoid valve in the outlet line regulates the cooling flow, which is sustained by a recirculation pump, through the heat exchanger. The plate style design allows cooling water and oil to flow side by side through alternating plates. The cooled oil then passes through the filter element and returns to the reservoir. The cooling water is either discharged or routed to a water chiller.The air cooler works as follows: The recirculation pump pulls oil from the hydraulic oil reservoir and sends it to the external heat exchanger. A temperature switch mounted on the reservoir monitors the oil temperature and regulates the air flow to the heat exchanger through a signal to the control panel to initiate power to the fan. Both systems feature a dual scale level/temperature sight gauge on the side of the reservoir to visually monitor the oil temperature.

To answer the question which of the alternative cooling systems is suitable for a particular application, environmental influences as well as the installation conditions have to be taken into consideration. Basically, the air cooler only works reliably up to an ambient temperature of about 30°C (86°F): For the efficient operation of such a system, the ambient temperature has to be at least 10°C (50°F) cooler than the temperature of the hydraulic oil. If the thermometer rises above this value, the cooling power decreases rapidly. Indeed, the pump still runs at higher temperatures – the automatic shut-down does not occur until the oil reaches 62°C (144°F); however, exceeding the recommended maximum temperature may have a negative effect on the lifetime of the high pressure seals in the intensifier.

Advantages of the Air Cooler

Anyway, the air cooler has its advantages, too. The water cooler as the standard option for KMT STREAMLINE pumps may be slightly cheaper in the initial purchase, however, this price advantage is quickly put into perspective: If a water cooler is installed without an additional chiller for the cooling water, further operating expenses are incurred as the water directly goes to the drain after one turn in the cooling circuit,. A 50 hp pump for example can have a cooling water consumption of 10 l/min. Depending on water costs and running times, the system creates operational costs which can be avoided using an air cooler. These costs can be saved by reusing the water. To do so, the machine operator has to connect an external chiller to cool down the used water before reintroducing it into the cooling circuit. Yet, the costs for such a chiller may actually amount to three times the additional costs of the air cooler. So considering the total costs, the air cooler is the more cost-effective alternative after all.

Regarding the installation effort, the air cooler also comes out front. This option provides the buyer with a ready-to-use system. In contrast, installing the water cooler necessitates either a set-up of the chiller or of the drain for the cooling water. So an air cooler is particularly advantageous for smaller companies which have no access to an already existing cooling system. Additionally, the exit air from the air cooler can be used to heat up small buildings.

Advantages of the Water Cooler

A water cooler may pay off in case the machine operator can dispose of cheap water, for example a river or some other water bodies close to the location of the installation. Additional costs still cannot be completely avoided though: When feeding the water cooler via a body of flowing or standing water, an additional pump probably becomes necessary to reach the minimum inlet water pressure of 2.5 bar.

However, in regions regularly and permanently reaching 30°C (86°F) ambient temperature or more, there is no alternative to a water cooler as the functionality of an air cooler meets its natural limitations. The same is true for large pump networks consisting of 4 to 5 or more machines. If air coolers are used in such cases, they will create air turbulences which may be more or less strong depending on the type of building and which delimit the cooling system’s efficiency. Additionally, the large amount of exit air created by the many systems heats up the environment and makes a cooling down just with air impossible.

What’s the best System?

To put it in a nutshell, the air cooler is the more cost-effective alternative compared to the water cooler regarding purchasing and operating costs, but it cannot be used in every circumstance. For high average ambient temperatures or large pump networks, water coolers are the more reliable option. The highest flexibility though is achieved with a combination system as KMT offers for its high pressure pumps. Particularly in regions with occasional temperature peaks of above 30°C (86°F), the cost-effective air cooler can be combined with the more reliable water cooler. In such a combination system, the air cooler is the main cooling system and the water cooler is switched on only if needed.